Wanted: pro-consumer voices on fund boards

Part of me thinks the Financial Conduct Authority deserves all the flak that comes its way. For a national regulator, its repeated failure to prevent major scandals happening, and the leaden-footed way it responds when they do, are plain embarrassing.

Another part of me wishes it one last chance to prove its worth. Call me a hopeless optimist, but after decades of regulatory capture, there are signs the FCA is finally waking up to its responsibility to consumers. Given time, I’m quietly hopeful that Nikhil Rathi will do a better job in charge at Endeavour Square than his hapless predecessor, Andrew Bailey.

There are, however, two caveats. First, it needs to ensure that when it acts, the changes it makes are in no way open to interpretation. Secondly, when (inevitably) companies choose to interpret them differently, they are swiftly and soundly brought into line.

A perfect example is the requirement for authorised fund managers (AFMs) to have independent non-executive directors (iNEDs) with whom they’ve had no prior relationship.

When it first proposed the move three years ago, the regulator explained that AFM boards were often failing to balance the interests of their investors and shareholders. This, it said, was partly due to the fact that they were generally staffed exclusively by executives of the firm.

To help ensure that boards were subject to greater scrutiny and challenge, it proposed that AFMs appoint a minimum of two independent directors.

Original proposal watered down

As always happens with FCA consultation papers, the proposal prompted sustained lobbying, and when the change was introduced in April 2018, it was somewhat watered down. It was left to the companies themselves to decide on the number of iNEDs to appoint. The regulator also backed down on its original suggestion that the chairman should be independent too.

Nevertheless, the measure was a positive step and, theoretically, it should have forced AFMs to pay more attention to the interests of their investors.

So, what has happened in the intervening two years? Sadly, it's fair to say that the requirement for independent directors has not had the effect that the FCA had hoped it would.

Assessment of value reports

Part of the regulator's intention, for example, was that independent directors would have a major say on the preparation of so-called assessment of value (AoV) reports. These annual reports, which were introduced at the same time as the requirement for iNEDs, were designed to force AFMs to give more "robust consideration" to the value for money that their funds provided.

The first round of reports were published in 2020, and I don't know of any impartial observer who has had a positive word to say about them. True, some reports were better, and more transparent, than others. But many were little more than a whitewash.

A meta-analysis of 968 funds from 26 leading asset managers by Boring Money showed that only 3% of funds were deemed not to be delivering value. The reports published by Hargreaves Lansdown and St James’s Place - neither of whom is particularly known for their commitment to value for money - were singled out for criticism.

A report by the CFA Institute published in February this year concluded that many value assessments fail to meet the spirit of the FCA requirements. While reporting on fund performance was generally adequate, the Institute found that reporting on risk, liquidity and ESG factors was largely missing.

Worryingly, it also appears that AoV reports are being routinely ignored by financial advisers. Research by The Lang Cat showed that almost 94% of advisers paid no attention to them whatsoever. Mike Barrett, a spokesman for the consultancy, said the most common response from advisers was cynicism about the wisdom of "asking asset managers to mark their own homework".

Why haven't iNEDs helped?

There are some obvious questions to ask here about the role of the newly appointed independent directors. What part have iNEDs played in compiling AoV reports? If those independent directors were serious (as they should be) about ensuring that investors receive value for money, why aren't the reports more candid about the VfM provided? And will the second round of AoV reports, which are just starting to be published now, be any more meaningful than the first?

Unfortunately, in answer to that last question, we are probably heading for more of the same. A recent report by the Fund Board Council (FBC) found that half of independent directors expect to spend less time completing their AoV reports this year than they did in 2020.

The iNEDs surveyed also admitted that their approach to the assessments the second time around had largely gone unchanged. Around 35% of respondents said they "somewhat agree" there has been no change in approach since last year; 27.5% neither agreed nor disagreed, and 22.5% said they "somewhat disagree".

How to make the system work

So what’s the answer? What can the FCA do to ensure that iNEDs make a genuine difference? Here are four things that I would be prioritising if I were Nikhil Rathi:

  1. The FCA needs to go further on board independence and stipulate a minimum number of iNEDs. If necessary, it should also insist on majority independent boards. If that still doesn't have the desired effect, it should revisit its original suggestion of independent chairs.
  2. AFMs need clearer guidance on what constitutes an independent director. One thing I've learned about from ten years of writing about this industry is that almost no one involved in it is truly independent. We all have personal commercial considerations that affect the way we act. The bottom line is that iNEDs shouldn’t be "yes men". They need to have demonstrated a commitment to improving consumer outcomes.
  3. There needs to be a more clearly defined set of recommended practices on assessment of value reports. For example, they shouldn't refer to investment track records shorter than ten years. They should have to include all fees and charges, including the cost of transactions. And they should also be brief and written in plain English; some of the reports have been up to 200 pages long, while many contain meaningless jargon.
  4. Finally, it needs spelling out that it's the responsibility of fund boards - and iNEDs in particular - to address company culture. Shiv Taneja, chief executive of the Fund Boards Council, is right when he says there's more to showing you add value than producing a report. There's still a belief in the City that you enter asset management to enrich yourself rather than other people. Only when there are more pro-consumer voices on fund boards will we start to see the cultural change the industry is crying out for.

Successive regulators have allowed the UK fund industry to have the upper hand over consumers for far too long. I for one am willing to give them the benefit of any doubt that they’re serious about levelling the playing field. Along with AoV reports, having more independent directors on fund boards is a potential game-changer.

But the system isn't yet working as it should, and there's no time to waste in fixing it.

Author: Robin Powell

21st May 2021

Share this article: