
Three Ways to Create a Fairer Fund Industry
This is the time of year when children receive their end-of-year school reports. It’s fitting, then, that the FCA should have chosen this week to deliver its verdict on the first year of its Assessment of Value (AoV) regime, which requires the fund industry to demonstrate the value for money it provides.
Believe me, if this were a school report, fund managers would be kept in class for the summer holidays and made to re-sit the year. Page after page, the report is an absolute shocker.
To recap, the rules on AoV came into force in September 2019, as part of the remedies proposed in the regulator’s Asset Management Market Study. The AMMS found weak demand-side pressure on fund fees, resulting in uncompetitive outcomes for retail investors.
The new rules require fund managers to carry out a value assessment at least once a year and publicly report their conclusions, and to appoint independent directors (iNEDs) to their boards.
So, how did the industry do in Year One? Very badly. Between July 2020 and May of this year, the FCA visited 18 fund managers to review their AoV arrangements, and here are just some of the astonishing shortcomings they discovered.
And what was the fund industry’s response to these damning findings? Depressingly predictable. Jonathan Lipkin, Director of Policy, Strategy and Research at the Investment Association (IA), who has been at the trade body for 16 and a half years, admitted it was clear from the findings that the industry must "actively build on experience to date to ensure Assessments of Value deliver for investors”. The trade body, he said, "will continue to work with firms as they improve their processes for performing and reporting”.
The truth is this very same trade body has known for decades that the industry’s profit margins are unsustainably high. Alan and Gina Miller of the True and Fair Campaign pointed out in 2012 that profit margins in the fund industry were scandalously high at some four times that of comparable peers in the pharmaceutical industry. Instead, the industry and its mouthpiece association has lobbied hard against attempts by the regulator to strike a fair balance between the interests of its members and their customers. When, in 2015, the IA’s former Chief Executive, Daniel Godfrey, called into question the industry commitment to serving consumers’ interests, he was removed from office.
With a few exceptions, other interested parties such as fund platforms and investment consultancies have been strangely reluctant to condemn the industry for its lack of progress on AoV. Many have chosen instead to highlight the very few positives in the latest report.
Again, it is down to the age-old problem of not wanting to bite the hand that feeds. Asset management is awesomely lucrative, with many different beneficiaries, and it does not make commercial sense to be overtly critical.
So, what is the answer? How can we make the industry face up to its moral and professional obligations and get its act together on AoV?
I suggested one solution in my last blog: the appointment to fund boards of genuinely independent Directors who are genuinely focused on improving consumer outcomes.
The FCA says there are some examples of iNEDs making a positive difference, but it was disappointed at the way that many of them failed to challenge the way Executive staff and Directors approached AoVs. To quote their review, “We expect independent directors to ask the difficult questions we asked in this review; in practice we did not observe enough independent directors doing this.”
We cannot allow independent directorships to become just another carriage on the fund management gravy train. We do not need yes-men or yes-women; we need principled, courageous people who are prepared to fight the customer’s corner.
Something else the industry’s failure on AoV underlines is the urgent need for a consumer duty of care.
Again, it’s quite shocking that it has taken an Act in 2021 to progress a duty of care despite an FCA Discussion Paper in July 2018 on the subject and a published Feedback Statement in April 2019.
Thankfully, Parliamentarians have stepped in under the recently passed Financial Services Act 2021 and made provisions for the implementation of a proposed consumer duty that would create a new and higher standard of conduct by creating a greater focus on customers’ interests and outcomes. The Act led to the FCA issuing a consultation paper in May 2021, in which it said it wanted to see a higher level of consumer protection in retail financial markets, where firms compete vigorously in the interests of consumers.
The new Consumer Duty proposed would “set higher expectations for the standard of care that firms provide to consumers”. But stakeholders seeking to increase consumer protections and outcomes must beware as the ‘big boys’ will not give up protecting their self-interested behaviours without a fight via serious, well-funded lobbying.
For many firms, the regulator says, this new duty would require a “significant shift in culture and behaviour, where they consistently focus on consumer outcomes, and put customers in a position where they can act and make decisions in their interests.”
This is an idea whose time has surely come. We need to see firms putting themselves in their customer’s shoes, asking themselves questions such as “Would I be happy to be treated the way we treat our customers?”, or “Would I recommend my firm’s products and services to my loved ones?”. It is almost laughable that this needs to be stated but such is the anti-consumer culture of the sector.
In essence, its pitiful response to AoV has shown how lacking the industry is in principles, ethics and self-awareness, and how devoid it is of any sense of duty to those it is meant to serve. A statutory Consumer Duty of care, with substantial penalties for failing to comply, is now vital for bringing about the changes in attitude and behaviour we need to see.
Finally, this latest report shows yet again that we cannot expect the fund industry to mend its ways of its own accord. We need good people within financial services to stand up and be counted. We need regulators and policy makers to keep up the pressure on fund managers to provide better value. And we also need consumers to demand a fairer deal.
We very much urge you to exercise your civic consumer voice and respond to the FCA’s consultation on the proposed Consumer Duty before the deadline on 31st July. Using this online response form it will only take a few minutes. Also consider writing to your local MP.
And please support the True and Fair Campaign by signing up and sharing our content.
8th July 2021

Three Ways to Create a Fairer Fund Industry

Wanted: pro-consumer voices on fund boards

The Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) is vastly overpaying for investment management