The Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) is vastly overpaying for investment management

Pick up any local newspaper and chances are you’ll find an article about council finances under strain. Years of spending cuts have shaved services to the bone. Whether it’s roads full of potholes, or reduced opening hours for public libraries, the signs of decades of austerity are everywhere. And, after borrowing around £500 billion to cope with the pandemic, the Government is unlikely to loosen the purse strings any time soon.

Faced with such a crisis, Councils up and down the country are having to find new ways of doing more with less. But are they overlooking an obvious way to save substantial amounts of public money and deliver better outcomes?

New data obtained via a Freedom of Information request suggests they are.

The area of spending in question is the funding of pensions for Local Government workers. Far from reducing the amount they spend on the management of pension funds, it seems that many authorities are spending more on them than ever before.

Expenses up 20% in a year

Gloucestershire’s pension fund, for example, saw its overall investment management expenses soar by 20% to £7.8 million in the last financial year. The county spent £6.7 million in management fees — up 26% on the previous year — while performance fees rose by 4.4%, despite a 6% drop in the overall value of the fund.

The fund said rising costs were partly down to the fact that “some mandates have increased as a result of moving from passive to active managers”, and partly down to “increased investments to alternatives, particularly private equity and infrastructure, which are subject to higher fee rates”.

Gloucestershire certainly isn’t alone in increasing its allocation to such investments. Devon’s pension fund, for instance, has an allocation to alternatives of 26.6%. Five years ago, the allocation was just 15%. In that time, Devon’s investment management costs have shot up by 39%, reaching £16.5 million last year.

So far, though, Devon’s shift towards alternatives hasn’t translated into higher returns. Last year the fund registered a negative investment return, of -8 per cent, net of fees.

One of the biggest funds in the world

Britain’s LGPS is one of the biggest of its kind in the world, with 99 separate funds across the country, around 4.6 million members and circa £276 billion under management. It has a fiduciary responsibility to deliver the returns needed to pay scheme members’ pensions, as well as protect local taxpayers and employers from high pension costs.

Quite how seriously the LGPS take that responsibility is open to debate. Michael Johnson at the Centre for Policy Studies, for example, has warned in a series of reports that the system faces a crisis; that it has consistently overpaid active fund managers for poor returns; that it will eventually be unable to fulfil its obligations; and that urgent reforms are required to make it fit for purpose.

Interestingly, there’s a similar debate going on in the United States, where several states are struggling with pension deficits. In most cases, the problem is down to excessive fees. There have been several successful lawsuits against the trustees of public pension schemes, and the FBI is currently investigating allegations of wrongdoing against the trustees of the Pennsylvania schoolteachers' pension fund and the Chicago police pension fund.

Underperformance almost inevitable

For years, there has been a raft of academic and campaigner evidence that high costs in general, and allocating to alternative investments in particular, make underperformance by public pension funds almost inevitable.

In a study published in June 2020, Ludovic Phalippou, a professor of financial economics at the University of Oxford, challenged the claim that private equity outperforms public stock markets. He showed how, net of fees, returns from private equity funds were no better than those of public equity indices from 2006 through to the end of 2019. 

Phalippou blames a combination of “misleading performance information that was presented to investors, the fees being higher than those recorded in any other investment vehicles, and high transaction costs,” which he says lead to an outcome that is “unlikely to be positive for investors”.

The issue of high fees and LGPS is something Co-founder of the True and Fair Campaign, Gina Miller has been banging the drum loudly about since 2013.  Today, she is also increasingly worried today about the pressure of on LGPS to allocate to ESG / ethical products even though the sector is poorly regulated, guilty of widespread greenwashing and charging higher fees.

Taxpayers’ money being wasted

In a US study published in March this year, Richard Ennis, a former editor of the prestigious Financial Analysts Journal, showed how pension fund trustees were failing in their fiduciary duty by not making more use of low-cost index funds. By choosing more expensive funds, he showed, they were wasting $68 billion every year. On average, that costs each US taxpayer around $500 per year. 

This underperformance, Ennis demonstrated, was almost exactly equal to the amount of the fees charged by the investment professionals hired to invest the assets. In every other respect, the performance of the funds he analysed was indistinguishable from that of a combination of two or three stock and bond index funds.

In 2014 a report commissioned by the Department for Communities and Local Government and produced by Hymans Robertson recommended that the LGPS switched to passive funds for equities and bonds. Such a move, it said, would save £420 million in fees and charges every year — a figure that would be very much higher today.

Thankfully, the Government did act on one of Hymans Roberston’s recommendations, by asking LGPS funds to put forward proposals for reducing costs by pooling their investments.

Unfortunately, though, the recommendation that the LGPS moves away from actively managed funds for listed assets has largely been ignored — partly, one suspects, as a result of the concerted lobbying from the big asset management companies and investment consultancy firms which followed the report’s publication.

Public pensions are a big deal — not just for the members of those schemes but for all of us taxpayers who help to fund them; but also due to the wider social and economic consequences of pensioners not have enough funds for their retirement years.

It is now urgent that we had a serious debate about the LGPS.

Author: Robin Powell

10th September 2021

Share this article: