Campaigns:

Regulation

OPEN LETTER : True and Fair Open Letter to FCA Chair, Charles Randell disputing his responses re the FCA Complaints Scheme’s “solely and primarily responsible” test which the Campaign believe is contrary to law

5 July 2021

Response letter from Charles Randell, Chair of the FCA, to Questions Raised by The Millers re The New FCA Compensation Scheme

27 April 2021

CONSULTATION SUBMISSION : CP20/11: Complaints against the Regulators & Compensation Scheme

12 October 2020

The Financial Services Act 2012 requires the FCA to have in place a scheme to investigate complaints against them. It is the True and Fair Campaign’s view that the FCA’s proposals for this new Compensation Scheme are unfair, immoral, and illegal. In our submission, True and Fair highlights how the proposed scheme contravenes the Financial Services Act 2012 and breaches one of the FCA’s five regulatory objectives under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000.

ACTION PLAN : True and Fair Campaign 10 Point Action Plan To Improve and Protect the Integrity of UK Financial Services

24 September 2020

The True and Fair Campaign have drafted a pragmatic 10-Point Action Plan that would enable the FCA and the UK Financial Services Industry to improve and protect the integrity of the sector, as well as vastly improve customer outcomes.

REPORT : Asleep at the Wheel

25 February 2020

This report was triggered by the proposed appointment of Andrew Bailey as the new Head of the Bank of England.  It details the litany of regulatory failures under Mr Bailey’s watch that led to some the most egregious scandals in UK Financial Services – from the Lloyds Banking Group scandal to the Woodford Scandal.  The Report called for the Treasury Select Committee to reassess Mr Bailey’s suitability, rather than rewarding him for gross regulatory failures.

REPORT : Challenging the Bailey Appointment

21 February 2020

This report calls on the newly appointed Treasury Select Committee to launch an urgent independent inquiry into the appointment of Mr Andrew Bailey as the new Governor of the Bank of England and questions if he is a “fit and proper person” to hold this vital public office.

SUBMISSION : FCA Consultation Paper CP17 – Implementing Asset Management Market Study Remedies and Changes to Handbook

27 September 2017

SCM Direct/True and Fair Campaign Response to the FCA Consultation Paper (CP17/18) – Implementing Asset Management Market Study Remedies and Changes to Handbook

SUBMISSION : Response to The FCA Asset Management Market Study MS15/2.2

20 February 2017

As part of the Response, we analysed the retail classes of a significant number of active funds sold to UK investors and uncovered evidence of a complete lack of price competition whereby the underlying charge by fund managers has remained identical for many years – even post RDR.

Summary Review of Key Points Within the FCA Asset Management Market Study

18 November 2016

The 208 page FCA Study is a comprehensive and informed analysis of the numerous dubious practises that have dogged the UK Fund Management industry for decades. An industry that has lost its moral compass and the principle of putting customers first.  The True and Fair Campaign hopes that this FCA Report is a game changer and marks a cultural revolution within both the Regulator and the sector.

REPORT : UK Fintech and Robo Advice

6 July 2016

Fintech Folly – The Sense and Sensibility of UK Robo Advice

SUBMISSION : True and Fair Campaign Response to DWP DP15 Consultation on Transparency of Costs and Bid-Ask Spreads

4 May 2015

The True and Fair Campaign was initiated by the founders of SCM Private, Alan and Gina Miller, in 2012 to raise awareness of the lack of transparency within the UK investment management industry.

SUBMISSION : Response to the 2015/16 FCA Business Plan – Market Study on Asset Managers

24 March 2015

The UK regulator is behind many other national regulators in addressing misleading fees and marketing materials. Whoever forms the new government, one of their first actions should be to set up an independent inquiry into this vital industry regulator that pretends to safeguard the public’s savings and investments.

True and Fair Campaign Response to FSCP Report

1 November 2014

The True and Fair Campaign commends the Financial Services Consumer Panel (FSCP) for commissioning and publishing two independent reports and a summary paper ‘Collective Investment Schemes Costs and Charges’ seeking to interrogate investor protection – the findings supports all the True and Fair Campaign’s findings over the last three years.

True and Fair Manifesto – March 2014

1 March 2014

Millions of people are doing the right thing by saving, but they are being abused and left out of pocket through lack of competition, slick marketing and misleading fees. They deserve to be told the truth and the industry needs to remember the human face of what they do.
The True and Fair Campaign launches a ‘Manifesto for Change’ to vastly improve consumer protect and outcomes.

STATEMENT : MIFID II Victory

20 February 2014

True and Fair Campaign Celebrates as New EU Law brings reforms that will revolutionise consumer protection for UK savers and investors and end scandalous hidden charge fiasco.

SUBMISSION : IMA SORP Consultation

1 January 2013

The True and Fair Campaign responds to the Investment Management Association (IMA) regarding their proposed new SORP in which ‘The IMA has taken the opportunity to make other improvements to the SORP and to introduce a template for presenting information about performance and charges during the reporting period.’

In the response, the True and Fair Campaign details the reasons why we believe the proposed SORP fails to meet these objectives.

True and Fair Manifesto – September 2012

1 September 2012

The British public faces a minefield of hidden charges with regard to their pensions, investments and savings. The True and Fair Manifesto details a transparency agenda to resolve these issues.

REPORT : Promoting Trust and Transparency in the UK Investment Industry

1 February 2012

Landmark report detailing how British consumers (investors and pensioners alike) have been comprehensively misled by the UK Investment Management Industry in relation to fees and charges. Key issues outlined include: the multiplicity of hidden fees, lack of product transparency and the convoluted language used by the investment management industry.

The investment management industry has been given no regulatory or behavioural incentive to enhance transparency, so the report included a chapter proposing a Code and Labelling scheme to generate best practice.