Consultation Submission : CP20/11: Complaints against the Regulators & Compensation Scheme

The Financial Services Act 2012 requires the FCA to have in place a scheme to investigate complaints against them. It is our view, as the True and Fair Campaign, that the FCA’s proposals for this new Compensation Scheme are unfair, immoral, and illegal. If the proposed scheme came into force, they “would consider making a compensatory payment only where adequate documentary evidence of the loss has been provided, and the following further conditions have been met: - we are the sole or primary cause of the loss; and - there has been a clear and significant failure by us” making it near impossible to meet the requirements for compensation. In our contribution, True and Fair highlights how the proposed scheme contravenes the Financial Services Act 2012 and breaches one of the FCA’s five regulatory objectives under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. It begs the question as to who signed off this scheme Draft and Consultation; and whether that person should be considering their position within the FCA.

Summary

The Financial Services Act 2012 – Part 6, requires the FCA to have in place a scheme to investigate complaints against them, as opposed to complaints against the businesses they regulate. As detailed within the submission below, it is the view of the True and Fair Campaign that the FCA’s proposals for this new Compensation Scheme are unfair, immoral, and illegal.

Not only does the proposed scheme contravene the Financial Services Act 2012, it fragrantly breaches one of the FCA’s five regulatory objectives under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, namely “The protection of consumers”. It also fragrantly breaches one of its own three operational objectives, “securing an appropriate degree of protection for consumers”.

Were the proposed scheme to come into force, it is unlikely that there would be any compensation payments due to the proposal in 4.10 that “we would consider making a compensatory payment only where adequate documentary evidence of the loss has been provided, and the following further conditions have been met: – we are the sole or primary cause of the loss; and – there has been a clear and significant failure by us”.